Shots - Health News | NPR

The FDA proposes new targets to limit lead in baby food

Toxic metal can be harmful to developing brains. New lead targets are part of a broad FDA imitative to reduce children's exposure to the lowest levels possible.

Listen

New guidance calls for lower lead levels in food for babies and children under 2. Lead exposure can be harmful to developing brains.
New guidance calls for lower lead levels in food for babies and children under 2. Lead exposure can be harmful to developing brains. Jeff Greenberg | Universal Images Group via Getty

It's not possible to remove all traces of lead from the food supply, because the heavy metal is found throughout the environment and can be absorbed by plants. So traces are found in the vegetables, fruits and grains that are used to make baby food.

But as toxic metal exposure can be harmful to developing brains, the Food and Drug Administration is issuing new guidelines to reduce children's exposure to the lowest level possible.

The new FDA guidance calls for limiting lead concentrations in all processed foods intended for babies and children less than two years old. Lead concentrations should now be limited to 10 parts per billion in fruits, vegetables and meats packaged in baby food jars, pouches, tubs and boxes. The target is 20 parts per billion for dry cereals.

The FDA estimates these lower levels could result in a 24 to 27% reduction in exposure to lead resulting in "long-term, meaningful and sustainable reductions in the exposure to this contaminant from these foods," according to a statement by FDA Commissioner Robert Califf.

"We know that the less amount of these metals in babies' bodies, the better," says Dr. Aaron Bernstein, a pediatrician at Boston Children's Hospital and a member of the American Academy of Pediatrics. So, he says the goal should be to minimize how much lead a child is exposed to.

"Parents need to recognize that foods have metals in them naturally in some cases," he says. So it's best "to feed your child a variety of foods to the extent that's possible." Some foods will have more lead than others and a varied diet is also good for nutrition — so following "good nutritional guidance will also reduce exposure to these metals," Bernstein says.

The American Academy of Pediatrics has several tips for parents on how to reduce children's exposure to heavy metals: Serve a variety of foods, read labels, switch up your infant cereals and check your water supply for heavy metals.

In addition offer toddlers and young children sliced or pureed fruit instead of fruit juice, because some fruit juices can contain concerning levels of heavy metals.

"Fruit juices can have as much, if not more of these very metals we're trying to minimize," Bernstein says. And he says juice is a "sugar hit" for kids, so nutritionally it's a good thing to avoid.

The FDA says there has already been a dramatic decline in lead exposure from foods since the mid-1980s. Lead was phased out of gasoline and paint decades ago and there's currently lots of federal funding to replace old water pipes that contain lead, pushed through partly in response to shocking stories of lead poisoning in places like Flint, Michigan.

Dr. Leonardo Trasande, a pediatrician at NYU Langone Health, says the FDA is moving in the right direction with these new targets, but we've known about these toxins for decades, he says.

"As much as this is a baby step forward in limiting toxic exposures for children's health, the FDA has been glacial in its pace of addressing newer and emerging contaminants," he says.

Chemicals such as phthalates which are used in packaging can find their way into food. Trasande says we need to know how these compounds may also be impacting children's health.

Copyright 2023 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

Transcript :

A MARTÍNEZ, HOST:

The Food and Drug Administration has proposed new targets to limit lead in baby food. Exposure to the toxic metal can be harmful to developing brains. As NPR's Allison Aubrey reports, the new targets are part of a broad initiative at the agency to reduce children's exposure to the lowest levels possible.

ALLISON AUBREY, BYLINE: It's not possible to completely eliminate all traces of lead from the food supply since the heavy metal is found throughout the environment and can be absorbed by plants, including vegetables, fruits and grains. But the new FDA guidance calls for limiting lead concentrations to 10 parts per billion in fruits, vegetables and meats packaged in baby food jars or pouches. The target is 20 parts per billion for dry cereals. Here's pediatrician Aaron Bernstein of Boston Children's Hospital.

AARON BERNSTEIN: We know the less amount of these metals in babies' bodies, the better. And so the goal here is to really minimize.

AUBREY: The FDA says there's already been a dramatic decline in lead exposure from foods since the 1980s. Lead was phased out of gasoline decades ago. And there's currently lots of federal funding to replace old water pipes that contain lead. And when it comes to lead in food, the American Academy of Pediatrics says one strategy parents can use is to avoid giving fruit juice to young children, since some juices can contain heavy metals.

BERNSTEIN: Fruit juices can have as much, if not more of these very metals that we're trying to minimize. So it's nutritionally not very good. And you don't need to give a child any juice.

AUBREY: He says most juice is just a sugar hit for kids. Pediatrician Leonardo Trasande of New York University says the FDA is moving in the right direction with these new target limits for lead. But he argues more needs to be done.

LEONARDO TRASANDE: As much as this is a baby step forward, the FDA has been glacial in its pace at addressing newer and emerging contaminants.

AUBREY: Such as phthalates used in food packaging and other non-stick chemicals used throughout the industry. He says we need to know more about how these compounds may influence children's health.

Allison Aubrey, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.