This article is over 5 years old


Police Officers’ Union Sues Houston, Firefighters’ Union Over Pay Parity

On Friday evening, a State District Judge granted a temporary restraining order at the request of the HPOU. The TRO blocks for now the implementation of Proposition B.


Fire trucks
Andrew Schneider/Houston Public Media
This August 8, 2018, file photo shows HFD vehicles parked in front of Houston City Hall.

The Houston Police Officers’ Union (HPOU) has filed a lawsuit against both the City of Houston and the Houston Professional Fire Fighters Association, in an effort to block implementation of a charter amendment granting firefighters pay parity with police officers of equivalent rank. Houston voters approved the amendment, also known as Proposition B, earlier this month.

On Friday evening, State District Judge Kristen Brauchle Hawkins granted a temporary restraining order (TRO) at the request of the HPOU, the Houston Chronicle reported. The TRO blocks for now the implementation of the charter amendment.

According to the petition filed with the Harris County District Clerk, the police union is seeking an injunction to have the amendment declared unconstitutional. Among the reasons, the police charge that existing state law specifically prohibits tying Houston firefighters’ pay to that of other municipal workers. In effect, they argue, requiring pay parity limits the police union’s own collective bargaining rights.

The police union also contends that state law bans the setting of firefighter pay by ballot measure. This last argument is one that Mayor Sylvester Turner has made both before and since the passage of Proposition B. Earlier this week, Houston City Council voted to hire the law firm of Norton Rose Fulbright, as a first step in filing its own suit to block the charter amendment.

Turner’s office released the following statement: “Let me remind everyone that there is at least a $100 [million] cost every year to the passage of Proposition B, which the city cannot afford. It would lead to significant layoffs and a reduction of services. Some of those layoffs could involve police and firefighters. The City cannot afford to lose one first responder for public safety purposes. I believe people understand that. Placing the matter in court will clear up the issue of whether state law makes the proposition invalid.”

Both Turner and the police union campaigned actively against the passage of Proposition B in the months leading up to Election Day.

Patrick M. "Marty" Lancton, president of the Houston Professional Fire Fighters Association (HPFFA), released a statement calling the litigation initiated by the HPOU a “throw-down lawsuit” and added the police union “is a willing political pawn of a vindictive mayor,” in reference to Turner.