Fire Chief “frustrated” daycare owner fled to Nigeria

The Houston Fire Department and the State Department are still working to get daycare owner Jessica Tata back to the United States. Tata fled to Nigeria after a fire at her daycare center killed four children last week. She faces ten charges so far related to the fire. But the legal ramifications of bringing her back to this country are tricky. David Pitman reports.

The U.S. and Nigeria have an extradition treaty that dates back to the 1930s. It outlines a number of crimes that are eligible for extradition between the two countries. Reckless endangerment to a child, which is the charge against Tata, is not one of them.

“Article One of that treaty declares that an accused can be extradited for offenses that are listed in Article Three, and Article Three lists only one relevant defense, and that is manslaughter.” 

That’s Professor Jordan Paust with the University of Houston Law Center. He says Tata isn’t charged with manslaughter, but officials may still consider doing that.

“So I suspect that one of the things that the local prosecutors might want to look into is whether or not they think there are enough facts that allow a charge of manslaughter so that the United States then can request extradition of Nigeria.”  

Houston Police Chief Charles McClelland at the podium

Houston Police Chief Charles McClelland says arson investigators are working with multiple agencies to examine the evidence.

“You know, the State Department, our Marshals. We have officers that are on those federal taskforces that may assist. We’ve offered the fire department all of our assistance, technology, anything that we can do to bring this lady back to justice.” 
The District Attorney’s office has defended its actions that included at least four attempts by arson investigators to have charges filed against Tata last weekend. DA Pat Lykos hasn’t said whether manslaughter charges may be filed. 


David Pitman

David Pitman

Host, Morning Edition

Hi there. I’m glad you found me. Let me take a moment to answer some of the questions you might have about me and my job. I have worked as Morning Edition Host and reporter at News 88.7 since August of 2009. Previously, I hosted Morning Edition at WMFE in...

More Information